This song is one of my favorites to hear live, and I swear that’s not just because it’s off of my favorite album. There’s an intensity that you can really feel in the room during this one. It doesn’t have the same effect on the rest of the fans in the room, since some of them came to hear more Heartbreaker and Gold songs than from the rest of the catalog. But while they’re itching for him to bust out the harmonica, there are those of us who are more than happy to hear this one. It’s a very different energy than what you get out of a song like “Magick” or “Peaceful Valley”, and it’s something I really appreciate.
There are some lines in this song that are, to put it simply, terrifying. The best/worst is “I’m getting really cold and I’m looking at you/And you’re not moving.” No offense to a certain song off of Cardinology, but this is my favorite Ryan Adams song that features an aquatic disaster. I’ve always felt that the song deserved a bigger, more powerful ending than it got. It just fades out, while I’d like to hear it get the same treatment as “Political Scientist.”